495
u/Krocodilo 13d ago
You thought it was the start of something great... and disappointment hits you hard
→ More replies190
u/Woodfield30 13d ago
I think Gotye caught a lot of people out. His album did great because everyone loved that “Somebody” song but his other music is very much unlike that one song. I know my parents got stung by it!
80
u/CaptBranBran 13d ago
That happened to my parents with Train and "Drops of Jupiter", they listened to the whole album once and then sold it, but bought the song again when they discovered iTunes.
→ More replies29
u/jofloberyl 13d ago
what?! train has a lot of nice songs!
7
u/WhiskeyHotdog_2 12d ago
Honestly yeah, recently discovered their first album is amazing. Everything later is alright, but that first album is fire
→ More replies4
u/FinalMeltdown15 12d ago
I once heard someone describe Train as momcore and its hilariously accurate
32
u/GQDragon 13d ago
"Heart's a Mess" is even better. It's an amazing song. Dude has been MIA for ten years now.
19
→ More replies7
u/SuperMrTiddles 13d ago
He doesn’t have one real style of song but I generally like his stuff. For most people he’s a one hit wonder but outside of maybe a song or two I like pretty much everything he’s put out.
→ More replies16
u/CptBoomshard 13d ago
That was definitely how Gotye was for me. Also Fun. and Young the Giant.
15
u/OctaviusBlight 13d ago
Fun. Had maybe three songs which were highly regarded. Their other tunes were ok but nothing superb.
15
u/_Vetis_ 13d ago edited 12d ago
Fun.'s first album Aim and Ignite was, in my opinion, an indie pop masterpiece and then they got wayyyyy too big for their britches and decided every song had to be an anthem.
If you like fun, then Bleachers is something worth checking out. Its the guy who wrote most of the music.
Nate Ruess also has some solo stuff if you like the voice, Nothing Without Love isnt bad
→ More replies7
→ More replies4
300
u/zozi0102 13d ago
Thats when you force yourself to listen to all of their songs so you get the musical equivalent of Stockholm syndrome.
38
u/tweedsheep 13d ago
Me, listening to The Mission's entire discography just so I can say I did. Don't do it.
→ More replies16
u/YellowJello_OW 12d ago
Glad it's not just me. Not a single one of my friends likes my music and I've discovered that I've essentially conditioned myself to exclusively love a specific genre
9
u/ChuckZombie 12d ago
I did that a lot. "I paid for it, I'm gonna force myself to like it." Now I cringe when I hear Korn.
→ More replies9
u/D_Pichu 12d ago
When I first heard DARE by Gorillaz I fell in love with it and ended up buying the Demon Days Album. It sounded completely different that what I expected and was disappointed at first, but I still tried to listen to it over and over again to get to DARE. Still remains to be my favorite band to this day because of that lol
12
u/ThreadedPommel 12d ago
To be fair, gorillaz songs seem to have a weird effect where you don't really like them at first, but the more you listen to them the better they get.
→ More replies
1.9k
u/songfulqo
13d ago
•
check out its producer
145
u/el_aleman_ 13d ago
It's always great when an artist you like keeps working with a producer you like.
→ More replies93
u/deezx1010 13d ago
Eminem and Dr. Dre were magic together. Eminem's whole album tone became messy the less influence and time they spent on albums together.
Undoubtedly in my top 5 rappers of all time. Closer to top 2 than anything. But I hate how he's basically an incredible ultra lyricist rapper without direction last 6-7 years
15
u/PinkTalkingDead 13d ago
Yeah. Imo his last great album through n through was the Eminem show 👀 but that’s also when I stopped listening to him 24/7
→ More replies10
u/mycalvesthiccaf 12d ago
That's a problem with battle rappers. Their lyrical skills are absolutely top tier but damn they can't make a coherent record
670
u/zuzg 13d ago
And that's the story how the Arctic Monkey Album Humbug brought me to Queens of the Stone Age
178
45
u/NietzscheIsMyCopilot 13d ago
hellll yeah QOTSA, everything Josh Homme touches seems to turn to gold, Royal Blood is another example.
Also "....like clockwork" is the best album of the 2010's
25
u/ignore_me_im_high 13d ago
everything Josh Homme touches seems to turn to gold
Well, not everything, especially custody battles with his ex...
→ More replies15
u/imjusta_bill 12d ago
As much as I love Qotsa, Homme seems like ten pounds of crazy in a five pound bag. Dalle more so
→ More replies16
u/Shirlenator 13d ago
Anyone that is unaware of them should check out Them Crooked Vultures. Homme, Dave Grohl, and John Paul Jones.
→ More replies→ More replies7
u/AcadianMan 12d ago
Royal Blood is amazing considering it’s a drummer and a bass player/singer.
→ More replies11
u/OctaviusBlight 13d ago
Humbug is still the absolute best album of the 2000s for me. Still my favourite Arctic Monkeys record, though all of them standout so well.
9
5
u/FelixThunderbolt 12d ago
Kinda wild take, lmao. That's not even the best Arctic Monkeys album of the 2000s...
→ More replies8
u/Nikas_intheknow 13d ago
Finally something I am extremely passionate about. Have you also listened to The Last Shadow Puppets and Mini Mansions (side projects of those bands)? I promise they will not let you down!
→ More replies4
u/DaisyRidleyTeeth 12d ago
Similarly I found Alexandra Savior from Alex Turner who produced her album Belladonna of Sadness
48
u/dannydamaja 13d ago
How I found Clams Casino
15
u/mattcoady 13d ago
I just discovered Clams Casino is also an actual food dish and it looks pretty tasty.
4
u/axrael 13d ago
Worked in a seafood joint and I'd bust out the line that "you'll really hit the jackpot with our clams casino" gag quite a bit.
I had a slew of other seafood related puns I'd pull out as well.
→ More replies7
u/chazzeromus 13d ago
Got hooked with I’m God , then to 32 levels which was amazing. Been still looking for a high quality version of Angels instrumental
12
u/bellaciaopartigiano 13d ago
Every Q song that wasn’t produced by The Alchemist.
Well I shouldn’t say that, but man does Q make radio music that’s way worse than his other shit.
→ More replies40
u/TimmJimmGrimm 13d ago
Brilliant comment.
Please list some of your favourite producers that can do this Midas-touch to otherwise par musicians.
If you know of a few, please share!
60
u/ryan_piezo 13d ago
Literally anything Danger Mouse touches is great. He was the guy who wasn't cee-lo in Gnarls Barkley. He was the drummer for the broken bells. And he produced Demon Days by the Gorillaz, El Camino by The Black Keys and a whole bunch more.
16
u/Repost_Hypocrite 13d ago
I was going to say Danger Mouse too! That day when I found out that Danger Mouse influenced about 40% of the music I like I was floored
→ More replies14
15
8
→ More replies9
u/FuturePigeon 13d ago
Steve Albini. These are not par musicians, but he has a special talent.
“In 2004, Albini estimated that he has engineered the recording of 1,500 albums, mostly by underground musicians.[15] By 2018, his estimate had increased to several thousand.[2] More prominent artists that Albini has worked with include: Foxy Shazam,[23] Nirvana,[24] Pixies,[25] The Breeders, Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Mogwai, The Jesus Lizard, Don Caballero, PJ Harvey, The Wedding Present, Joanna Newsom, Superchunk, Low, Dirty Three, Jawbreaker, Neurosis, Cloud Nothings, Bush,[26] Chevelle,[27] Jimmy Page and Robert Plant (as Page and Plant),[28] Helmet,[29] Fred Schneider,[30] The Stooges,[31] Owls,[32] Manic Street Preachers,[33] Jarvis Cocker,[34] The Cribs,[35] the Fleshtones,[36] Nina Nastasia,[37] The Frames,[38] The Membranes,[39] Cheap Trick,[40] Motorpsycho,[41] Slint,[42] mclusky,[43] Labradford,[44] Veruca Salt,[45] Zao,[46] The Auteurs[47] and Spare Snare.[48]”
→ More replies7
u/realunnamed 13d ago
yeah like idk 14 years ago i was in my apprenticeship and working alone wielding and cutting big water pipes i was alone my first time and they trustet me i can do it i was turning the raido really loud and was vibing to some radio and i heard a kylie minogue song and i was like damn thats a banger. i searched for it found it but the rest ofh er songs was not so much this good.. i checked the producer and it was calvin harris. checked him out he didnt had songs done for himself yet he just produced bangers after bangers for idfferent artists. was rly nice find
3
5
u/CaffeinatedGuy 13d ago
Spotify doesn't show that info, and definitely doesn't make it searchable.
→ More replies4
u/nin10dorox 12d ago
There's a "show credits" option on spotify that shows songwriter and producer.
→ More replies→ More replies4
893
u/-GreyWalker- 13d ago
If this happens to you, look at who wrote the song, if it has the artists name and someone else, look at the someone else. There's a crappy loophole in the music industry called write a word get a third. Meaning, if the artist changes or adds a word to the song they get a 3rd of the writing credit.
291
103
u/rich519 13d ago
I’ve heard it’s helpful to check the producer too. They have a lot of influence over how the song sounds and that can carry over between multiple bands/singers.
70
u/Krabbypatty_thief 13d ago
Yep this is the real tip. Producer’s style and quality is usually alot more consistent than an individual artist
→ More replies29
→ More replies15
u/2hi4stimuli 13d ago
look no further than Rick Rubin or Alchemist production credits. They seem to work only with people they actually clicked with and really make a specific sounds when they’re together.
→ More replies69
u/rowan_damisch 13d ago
There's a crappy loophole in the music industry called write a word get a third.
That would explain why the songs who only repeat the same five lines over and over again somehow needed a shitton of people to be written.
→ More replies21
u/bunglejerry 12d ago
Writing credits are getting weird. Your average Kanye West song has, like, 20 songwriters and 10 producers. Apparently Kanye will credit pretty much everyone who's in the room when the song is being made.
It's a bit silly, but the opposite is silly as well, where a collaborative process results in a song that is credited to just one person. I remember Andy Summers of the Police being a little miffed when Puff Daddy's "I'll be Missing You" went stratospheric because only Sting got a cut (Sting is the sole credited writer of "Every Breath You Take") despite the Puff Daddy song being built around the guitar luck, which Summers said he wrote himself. That's not right either.
→ More replies12
11
6
u/dope420boy 13d ago
If you have Apple Music, scroll the bottom of the lyrics for that song and it will have who wrote it. Thanks for sharing this. I did know that was a thing
→ More replies→ More replies5
u/Plethora_of_squids 12d ago
I mean sometimes singers just work with songwriters to make music without any sort of trickery going on
I listen to some genres of Japanese music and it's really not uncommon to see a singer and a songwriter, or even a singer, lyricist, and arranger. The fact that the singer tends to get most of the attention though, even when the singer is literally just a glorified text-to-speech programme) is a well established issue, the problem is that that happens because the singer is the most instantly recognisable part of a song.
→ More replies
399
u/newenglandredshirt 13d ago
Lol. That was my mom when she discovered Good Riddance (Time of Your Life) by Green Day. I popped in one of the CDs I had, and she couldn't make it through the first song.
64
u/eckliptic 13d ago
She may like some of the songs in American Idiot, more similarities to Good Riddance
→ More replies90
u/SniffMyRapeHole 13d ago
I was alone
51
31
→ More replies8
→ More replies6
u/parkingspace 12d ago
Well.... Let her listen to Wake Me Up, When September Ends. That will be another she will like.
71
13d ago
[deleted]
27
u/Tributemest 13d ago
Was about to mention this song, you can tell they added the fuzzed out guitar on top of one of their regular songs in order to cash in on the "grunge" craze, but it works, that song punches hard!
→ More replies4
u/Schootingstarr 12d ago
That was the biggest issues with albums back then.
Even from big swingers like Michael Jackson
223
221
u/MinglinSingle 13d ago
This was me with Finger Eleven back in the day when Paralyzer came out.
25
u/todd_dayz 13d ago
Their albums from before paralyzer were the good stuff, anything after that wasn’t that great.
→ More replies14
u/turkeytime3 13d ago
Yeah I was gonna say, their first album is nothing but bangers.
→ More replies4
70
u/Arugula_Cautious 13d ago
That was all of us. That song is amazing but the band is booty
35
u/CaptBranBran 13d ago
I dodged a bullet, back in the day, I only had enough money to buy one album and it was between the Finger Eleven album or Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace by Foo Fighters.
→ More replies8
u/MagicMarshmelllow 13d ago
‘Slow Chemical’ is a jam, although it was basically written as a theme for a wrestler so it had foundation.
→ More replies16
9
36
13d ago edited 11d ago
[deleted]
→ More replies22
u/MinglinSingle 13d ago
Yeah, that's their other one. When Paralyzer came out I remembered One Thing and went "oh it's the same guys, their other songs are probably pretty good too!" But no... all trash
15
u/Xo-Qo 13d ago
They have two other tracks that I found through gaming before Paralyzer. Good Times and Stay In Shadow. Maybe it's just Burnout and SSX nostalgia.
11
u/VampireFist 13d ago
Dude, Burnout 3's OST is an all time best.
Stay in Shadow is, in my opinion, a better song than Paralyzer, which might also be because I had like 400 hours in that game back on the original Xbox.
→ More replies15
u/XVUltima 13d ago
That's the opposite for me. Paralyzer was my least favorite of their songs, but it was the only one the radio ever played.
23
u/EM_CEE_PEEPANTS 13d ago
Paralyzer always pissed me off because it sure seemed like a reskinned "Take Me Out" by Franz Ferdinand.
→ More replies12
141
u/ballerina_wannabe 13d ago
I feel the same way about authors, but it’s so much worse when you’ve spent a few hours getting partway through a book only to realize it’s not getting any better.
→ More replies31
u/KaamDeveloper 13d ago
Artemis by Andy Weir. That shit made me apprehensive towards Project Hail Mary (which turned out so much better)
→ More replies13
109
u/Northerleyfire 13d ago
There are definitely artists who are consistently excellent, and it's wonderful to find them.
→ More replies16
u/PsChampion_007 13d ago
Examples?
7
→ More replies25
u/witchelina 13d ago
Aurora. Florence and the Machine.
5
u/PinkTalkingDead 13d ago
Is FATM new album good? I saw her on instagram promoting it yesterday
→ More replies→ More replies5
103
u/Anustart_07734 13d ago
That’s how Maroon5 swindled me in the beginning
93
u/OctaviusBlight 13d ago
To be fair, Maroon 5 bamboozled a lot of people with how good their first album was. I was never as disappointed as I was with Maroon 5's music evolution.
→ More replies18
31
u/Pyro636 13d ago
I kinda get it though. Songs About Jane is a really good pop rock album so whatever they made next would either have to be more of the same (tough to do and have it be better) or pick one of the genres and double down. With all of the good songwriting talent they have, a dude with a really strong pop voice, and pop being much more lucrative I'd probably do the exact same thing unless I was sure I had something really cool or important to say with rock.
At least I think it's really cool that an entire band transitioned in to pop instead of just their lead singer ditching them to go solo pop.
→ More replies24
104
13d ago
That's my entire music collection. People ask me what bands or artists I like and I'm like "I have no idea. I just like songs."
→ More replies35
u/willitevergetbetter- 13d ago edited 12d ago
Damn I thought I was the only one. I don't really have fave artists - I just like songs.
→ More replies
34
13d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies10
u/DaringDomino3s 13d ago
If you were lucky it was like the first or last track but they always put it in 3rd or next to last somewhere to make you fast forward or listen to their other songs
→ More replies
25
u/paracog 13d ago
Then you find out that this song is one the artist doesn't like very much.
→ More replies
70
65
22
u/horrorkesh 13d ago
My music playlist is such a hodgepodge of like 900 different songs because of this very reason
20
u/Fr31l0ck 13d ago
Even worse is relistening to the song you liked and realizing you don't even like that song.
→ More replies
19
u/Rouge_means_red 13d ago
Or when you find an amazing album and find out the band just decided to change their genre after it
→ More replies9
u/Uceninde 13d ago
Everyone who loved Panic! at the Disco's first album feels this in their soul, lol.
→ More replies
101
u/UnhappyStrain 13d ago
Or when u find a band and like all their songs besides one singular one.
→ More replies91
u/TripinChikin 13d ago
Usually every "perfect" album for me has 1-3 songs i skip. The others are just too good and has enough emotional significance for me to consider it perfect
→ More replies34
14
u/Antnee83 13d ago
Kind of in the same vein, I love every single Silverchair album- yeah even Young Modern. So I was pretty excited when I found out that Daniel Johns had a solo album!
...It's fucking beyond terrible.
→ More replies
40
u/thiccums42069 13d ago edited 13d ago
I felt that way about nirvana and now the song I thought was their only good song is the only song i actively avoid so maybe just come back later and give them another shot
→ More replies21
56
u/mondegr33n 13d ago
Just throwing this out there: A lot of people are saying this is a one-hit wonder thing but there are many popular, well-established bands that just have 1 or 2 songs that are more accessible or whatever than the rest of their discography. That doesn’t make them 1 hit wonders. For example, some people only know or like “My Girls” from Animal Collective or “Creep” by Radiohead or “1979” from Smashing Pumpkins but none of those are one-hit wonders- they’re just some of the more popular/accessible hits from those groups.
→ More replies
11
11
u/Knight-of-Neekolul 13d ago
Worse yet, Spotify recommends songs/artists based on that artist's one single song you actually like. I often find myself thinking, "what the heck is playing in the back?" and then see "based on other artists you enjoy.
9
u/Fkingcherokee 13d ago
At least I don't have to buy the CD before I figure this out anymore. I don't know how many times I spent $15 just so I could have one song.
25
u/chrisvolume 13d ago
This is how I feel about Flume…
→ More replies23
u/Dancin_Wit_Da_Czars 13d ago
Which song? Flume has a lot of great songs, but so much is so very experimental that I can totally get having a bad time with an album.
→ More replies14
u/TermFine7944 13d ago
im the opposite lol, i feel like 65% of flume songs are kinda generic mall edm, but some of his songs like Voices, High Beams, Never Be Like You), genuinely sound good and fun to me
→ More replies8
u/Seano151 13d ago
He helped create future bass but has moved on since. That’s why a lot of his older stuff sounds more generic
→ More replies
27
u/OldComfort3669 13d ago
Lol, how many people have bought an album or a CD just for a single song?
28
u/FILTER_OUT_T_D 13d ago
Well I bought Jamiroquai’s Traveling Without Moving back in the 90s because of Virtual Insanity, but it turns out that was a great purchase that led me to who is now one of my favorite bands!
→ More replies13
u/LadyMirkwood 13d ago
This was my bane of the 90s, buying an album with my meagre pocket money only to find out it was shit
→ More replies4
u/sirspider 13d ago
I bought Alien Ant Farm's 2nd album for the Smooth Criminal cover. Listened to it exclusively for like... a year? One day I accidentally forgot to set it on repeat and ended up hearing the rest. That album has some great songs. Movie, Attitude, and Wish amongst them.
→ More replies
28
u/PocoPoto 13d ago
I fell in love with modest mouse's float on but couldn't get into any other of their songs Sadge.
9
u/Girlsontheinternet 13d ago edited 13d ago
I recommend "The World at Large". Not an easy summer bop like Float On at all, but it's got very wanderlust energy like Float On. I feel like those two songs go together like yin and yang.
→ More replies5
u/stay-a-while-and---- 13d ago
We Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank is an amazing album. Used to not like the song Dashboard until I listened to the whole album
→ More replies→ More replies5
7
u/WoahJimmy 13d ago
It hurts so bad! That feeling of excitement you get when finding a new song by a new artist then going to listen to their discography and each song steals your hope until finally you just act as if it never happened and listen to the new song with leas enthusiasm
7
6
5
10
u/mabond 13d ago
Effile 65...
→ More replies7
u/DaneColeson 13d ago
People always says this because they’ve only ever heard “Blue”. Europop and Contact! are two full albums of bangers that largely get ignored
→ More replies4
u/kronicle_gaming 13d ago
That Europop album is crazy good! The Edge, Living in a Bubble, My Console, Your Clown…man such a good nostalgic album my friends and I listen to every now and then
→ More replies
4
u/Jkranick 13d ago
Back in the olden days of the 80s, you would have to shell out anywhere from $10-$12 to find out that the rest of the album sucks donkey balls. It was a massively risky time in music purchasing. Word-of-mouth from older siblings was key.
→ More replies
4
u/Crying4alapdance 13d ago
It's maroon 5, uncle cracker, and Bon Jovi all owe me $20 each.
→ More replies
4
u/roxinmyhead 12d ago
Except Billy Joel. Find a Billy Joel sing you love and trust me there will be at least 4 others you love....because... so... many... songs.... to choose from.
Sidenote... some journalist who hated Billy Joel (grew up nearby I think) decided he would listen to all his songs and then write an detailed article about how and why he hated his music....wait for it.... instead he ended up writing an article about how he had been wrong and why he loved Billy Joel's music
→ More replies
2.4k
u/celiandreyi 13d ago
Everyone has their own personal One Hit Wonder list.